"All I can do is be me, whoever that is."
Bob Dylan
Recently I was waxing enthusiastic to a friend about an artist/tune I had heard (Sia / Soon We'll Be) and she asked what kind of music it was. I found myself fumbling: "Not rock… not exactly pop… not jazz…". I simply couldn't come up with an accurate label.
It made me recall an incident in the late 80's. My significant other at the time was writing a paper on the subject of Reggae for her Ethnomusicology course. I arranged for us to have dinner with a music business acquaintance in Toronto who was an expert. It was a fruitful meeting that not only helped my gf produce a paper that her professor subsequently used as a teaching aid, but opened my eyes to many things about the social/political origins of one of my fave musical genres.
During the post-meal chit chat the subject of awards came up and Daniel suggested it was becoming a difficult subject, citing as an example the fact that the previous year Sade won an award as "Best Jazz Vocalist". (Was there ever a woman as utterly cool as Ms Adu? Not in my mind.) The point was obvious: if Sade is a Jazz artist, what were Ella Fitzgerald and Mel Torme? Labeling had reached a difficult point.
When I was a teenager, popular music was simple: There was rock and there was R&B. You liked one or the other. The kind of music you listened to was part of who you were - a big part of identity you were developing. There were vague sub-genres, of course. Did you like more edgy, blues influenced rock or lighter, melodic pop. Were you a Stones guy or a Beatles guy? And in the UK there was that peculiar war between rock'n'roll (rockabilly - old school - Elvis, Gene Vincent, et al) and rock leading to the infamous Mods/Rockers weekend punch-ups in Brighton. (To learn about that amusing social blip check out the under-rated, overlooked classic film backed by The Who: Quadrophenia.)
Naturally, as recording technology developed, communications media grew and more talent entered the pool rock and R&B evolved giving rise to Disco, Fusion and everything since. Early on though, it was reasonably clear-cut: Rock or R&B.
I often tell people I am glad I am not really young. The pressures, the influences, the choices are just so much greater than those that my generation or Gen X had to confront. I often think we older folk just don't get how hard it is for kids. Aside from drugs, sex, politics etc. I wonder that all teenagers are not barking mad when they now have to choose which of the following define them (courtesy of Wikepedia) - and this is just from one genre - electronic:
* Ambient
o Ambient house
o Ambient industrial
o Ambient techno
o Black ambient
o Dark ambient
o Drone music
o Lowercase
o Psybient
o Space music
* Breakbeat
o Baltimore Club
o Big beat
o Broken beat
o Chemical breaks
o Florida breaks
o Nu skool breaks
o Progressive breaks
* Disco
o Cosmic disco
o Eurodance
o Euro disco
o Hi-NRG
o Italo dance
o Italo disco
o Nu-disco
o Spacesynth
* Downtempo
o Acid jazz
o Balearic Beat
o Chill out
o Ethnic electronica
o Glitch
o Illbient
o Minimal Electronica
o New Age music
o Nu jazz
o Trip hop
* Electronic music
o Berlin School
o Electroacoustic
* Electro
o Electro-hop
o Electro backbeat
o Freestyle music
o Techno bass
* Electronica
o Electropop
o Folktronica
o Glitch
o IDM
o Nu Jazz
o Trip hop
* (UK) Garage (UKG)
o 2-step
o 4×4
o Bassline
o Breakstep
o Dubstep
o Funky
o Grime
o Speed garage
* Hardcore/Hard dance
o Bouncy techno
o Breakbeat Hardcore
o Breakcore
o Darkcore
o Digital hardcore
o Doomcore
o Freeform hardcore
o Gabber
o Happy hardcore
o Hardstyle
o Jumpstyle
o Makina
o Noisecore
o Speedcore
o Terrorcore
o UK Hardcore
o J-Core
* House
o Acid house
o Bubblegum dance
o Chicago house
o Dark house
o Deep house
o Disco house
o Electro house
o Fidget house
o French house
o Freestyle house
o NY Garage
o Ghetto house
o Grind house
o Hi-NRG
o UK Hard house
o Hip house
o Italo house
o Jumpstyle
o Kwaito
o Latin house
o Merenhouse
o Minimal house/Microhouse
o Progressive house
o Scouse house
o Skacid
o Tribal house
o Tech house
* Industrial
o Ambient industrial
o Cybergrind
o Dark ambient
o Dark electro
o Death industrial
o Electronic body music
o Electro-industrial
o Futurepop
o Industrial DnB
o Industrial metal
o Industrial rock
o Industrial techno
o Japanoise
o Martial industrial
o Neofolk
o Noise
o Power noise
* Jungle music/Drum and bass
o Clownstep
o Darkstep
o Drumfunk
o Futurestep
o Hardstep
o Intelligent drum and bass
o Jump-Up
o Liquid funk
o Neurofunk
o Raggacore
o Sambass
o Techstep
o Trancestep
* Rock/Punk influenced electronic music
o Alternative dance
o Cyber metal
o Dance-punk
o Dark Wave
o Digital hardcore
o Electroclash
o Electro rock
o Electropunk
o Ethereal Wave
o Industrial rock
o Industrial metal
o New Rave
o New Romantic
o New Wave
o Synthpop
o Synthpunk
* Techno
o Acid techno
o Detroit techno
o Freetekno
o Ghettotech
o Jtek
o Minimal
o New beat
o Nortec
o Techno rave
o Schranz
o Wonky techno
o Technopera
* Trance
o Acid trance
o Ambient trance
o Classic trance
o Dream trance
o Euro-trance
o Hard trance
o Hardstyle
o Nu-NRG
o Progressive trance
o Tech trance
o Uplifting trance
o Vocal trance
* Psychedelic trance/Goa trance
o Dark psy
o Full on
o Nitzhonot
+ Uplifting
o Psyprog
o Psybient
o Psybreaks
o South African psytrance
o Suomisaundi
* Nu rave
o Hardcore breaks
o Rave breaks
o Jungle techno
* Chiptune
o 8-bit
o Bitpop
o Demoscene music
o Chiptune
o Nintendocore
o Picopop
o Game Boy music
o Gamewave
* Oldschool jungle
o Ragga-jungle
o Intelligent jungle
o Darkside jungle
Lables! Yikes!